It is that one golden element that makes us love a photograph and not just like it. The book goes into detail about his theories on the studium and punctum of a photograph. This week ive been reading roland barthes book, camera lucida and would like to touch upon some of his ideas on what makes a. A photographs punctum is that accident which pricks me but also bruises me, is poignant to me. Conclusion of studium vs punctum they can both be present in the same photograph but the punctum often disturbs the stadium and changes peoples interaction with the subject matter, turning their liking of an image into a love. Studium and punctum, a new language which i feel i need to explore further here in order to get a better understanding. Studuim, which doesnt mean at least not immediately study, is a latin word which means. Barthes writes, however lightninglike it may be, the punctum has, more or less potentially, a power of expansion. Consider this part two of my previous post on barthes camera lucida. Oct, 2016 to seek the punctum would be to reverse the inner logic of its manifestations. Rumba under fire proposes we think differently about what it means for the arts and liberal arts to be in crisis.
Survivors of the siege of sarajevo discuss which book. The rare experience of punctum art history teaching resources. For the street photographer then, the punctum is not seen when taking the photograph and yet these punctums hold the greatest surprise for me and i class them as the magic or trophy in street photography. What does that book actually say about studium and punctum in photography. This second element which will disturb the studium i shall therefore call punctum. Punctum is the rare detail that attracts you to an image, barthes says its mere presense changes my reading, that i am looking at a new photograph, marked in my eyes with a higher value. T he punctum, which translates from latin as point resonates.
That is also why we may perceive that his examples do not support his theory. Mar 12, 20 the punctum is not always available in our everyday existence, and barthes describes it as lifegiving. I have especially tried to understand two terms that barthes invented for investigating photographs, studium and punctum. I saw this image at the impressions gallery, one of a series of images celebrating the shared history of the uk with pakistan.
Punctum can exist alongside studium, but disturbs it, creating an element which rises from the scene and unintentionally fills the whole image. Barthes describes how the punctum operates in relation to the studium. French philosopher roland barthes discussed his thoughts about photography in detail in his book, camera lucida. The studium accounts for the desire to study and understand the photograph. According to barthes, punctum is the quality which breaks or punctuates the studium. The punctum always turns into the studium when expressed in language. In part one of this podcast, we look at the first part of the book and focus on how studium and punctum can help us better understand photography. Reflections on photography, published posthumously, was born out of his grieving the death of his mother. Equant, punctum aequans, is a mathematical concept developed by claudius ptolemy in the 2nd century ad to account for the observed motion of heavenly bodies in camera lucida book, studium and punctum. Sep 20, 2016 the punctum for the iwo jima photo might be different for every viewer.
Mar 25, 2011 camera lucida is a short book, but with the winter garden photograph it begins all over again. The studium and the punctum studium is the element that initially gets your attention. My title comes from percys analogy of literary critic, roland barthes, looking at pictures. Barthes made, a distinction between what he called the studium and punctum.
In camera lucida, roland barthes speaks of the copresence of two elements in every photograph. The punctum breaks the banal nature of the studium and brings what the author describes as a punctuality to a scene. Barthes calls studium a kind of education civility, politeness that allows discovery of the operator. Studium indicates the factor that initially draws the viewer to a photograph. Camera lucida by roland barthes books the guardian.
Studium and punctum french philosopher roland barthes discussed his thoughts about photography in detail in his book, camera lucida. I think of myself as an avid reader, fiction, history, photography, sport, even literature but i found this short book difficult. The punctum is not always available in our everyday existence, and barthes describes it as lifegiving. The studium is the broad sense of what the image is about the where, when and what, of the image. Punctum and studium adeles learning blog context and. We specialize in neotraditional and nonconventional scholarly work that productively twists andor ignores academic norms. In his reflections on photography, camera lucida, roland barthes introduces a distinction between a studium and a punctum. In a coincidence of the kind mentioned by richard in his essay, i have recently returned to reading this book because a friend is reading it and would like to discuss barthess ideas. The first thing i see is her hand holding a cigarette. Reading studium and punctum in photography 35 embracement and a philosophical study of barthess cherished concept of le neuter mavor 2011. Barthes camera lucida, first published in, assumes that the automaticity of the camera distinguishes photography from traditional media. The numbers you find in brackets refer to pages in that version of the book.
He mentions studium which is the general and historical information present in an image, and punctum something that grabs us, that rises above the scene, that holds our gaze or. Finally, by way of barthess affective photographic concept see epigraph above, punctum indicates thought that pierces and disturbs the wednesdayish, businessasusual protocols of both the generic university studium and its individual cells or holding tanks. Punctum is a capacity that hits you, and not anything that could be read out of the image as part of the studium. Analysing the vernacular photograph using roland barthes. Equant, punctum aequans, is a mathematical concept developed by claudius ptolemy in the 2nd century ad to account for the observed motion of heavenly bodies in camera lucida book. In his book camera lucida, the french philosopher roland barthes talks about subjective perception of photographs. Jul 01, 2008 this week ive been reading roland barthes book, camera lucida and would like to touch upon some of his ideas on what makes a photograph stand out.
His thoughts about the distinction between the studium and punctum of the photograph are particularly well known. A whole book even a short one to discover something i know at first glance. Social sciences, general gaze analysis photographers criticism and interpretation works photography. Suddenly every photograph is for barthes a memorial. We then explored the concept roland barthes explored in his book camera lucida, about an image having a studium, which is a mixture of denotations and connotations, it is what we can know about the photo based on existing knowledge of historical and social context. It was suggested that i should read camera lucida 1, the last work of french literary theorist and philosopher roland barthes. The book s principal, though not necessarily explicit theme, is the phenomenon of human plurality, analysed with the help of carefully defined notions of labour, work and action.
Joy a medievalist and advocate of open access and nicola masciandaro brooklyn college, cuny, who left the project in 2012. Studiumpunctum we then explored the concept roland barthes explored in his book camera lucida, about an image having a studium, which is a mixture of denotations and connotations, it is what we can know about the photo based on existing knowledge of historical and social context. It should be noted that presenting examples of punctum is an impossible mission. French postmodernist intellectual roland barthes, pondering the studiumpunctum distinction with the aid of nonfiltered gauloises. In roland barthes work camera lucida, he introduces two photographic concepts. Reading studium and punctum in steve mccurry and raghu rais photography. Facebook is showing information to help you better understand the purpose of a page. His efforts aim to fashion an altogether customized frameworkone that is distinct from alreadydetermined accounts of images and representationin which one can classify photography, so as to get at its essence, or noeme. Punctum definition at, a free online dictionary with pronunciation, synonyms and translation.
I had previously heard of studium and punctum but had not read the original book. The punctum punctuates the studium and as a result pierces its viewer. How does the studium and the punctum operate for you, consider what affects and moves you personally. The book develops the twin concepts of studium and punctum. Studium and punctum roland barthes thomasfrederickstaples. Congolese soldiers find their loneliness reflected in the lyrics of rumba songs. For photographers we always strive for this punctum.
This can be based off of a persons particular interest or likes. Camera lucida andre kertesz roland barthes military coup work abroad his travel great photographers documentary photography photojournalism. This week ive been reading roland barthes book, camera lucida and would like to touch upon some of his ideas on what makes a photograph stand out. Jun 28, 2018 in his book camera lucida, the french philosopher roland barthes talks about subjective perception of photographs. Punctum books, stylized as punctum books, is an openaccess and printondemand independent publisher based in brooklyn, new york, united states history. We have decided to go our separate ways in publishing ventures and will now be pursuing new, independent projects. Reading studium and punctum in steve mccurry and raghu. In our shop youll find zines, art, and other items weve made together or individually.
Punctum is an object or image that jumps out at the viewer within a photograph that accident which pricks, bruises me. Barthes camera lucida, annotation by kasia houlihan. It is the detail which reveals the givenness of the studium. Survivors of the siege of sarajevo discuss which book they would have never burned for fuel. Podcastroland barthes, studium and punctum inspired eye. And it would be very individual whatwho is speaking and what is said. Aug 22, 2014 barthes senala dos elementos en toda fotografia.
The studiumpunctum distinction is interesting, but its only marginally related to the book s main point. In order to truly understand the way in which the studium and the punctum operate for you, one must first come to terms with how they were initiated in roland barthes book camera lucida. Roland barthes camera lucida, part one leicaphilia. Key notions in this book are studium and punctum, both notions invented for the occasion. It is simultaneously an inquiry into both the nature and the essence of photography as well as a. The ambiguity of the book s title lends itself to the many levels on which the text addresses media theory, ranging from the very. You wouldnt know it, however, by reading about the book in the usual echochamber. Camera lucida was a short book published in 1980 by roland barthes and it was the last book he ever wrote. See actions taken by the people who manage and post content. Punctum books, stylized as punctum books, is an openaccess and printondemand independent publisher based in brooklyn, new york, united states. The studium is the photographs overt agenda, which might include a view, the person, an event of drama. Studium and punctum published on october, 2016 in essays by franek korbanski i am taking a look at a photograph of her, taken presumably in her fifties or sixties.
Barthes book, is simultaneously an enquiry into the nature and essence of photography and a eulogy to his then recently deceased mother. Barthes camera lucida part 1 the last one thousand. Definitions punctum can exist alongside studium, but disturbs it, creating an element which rises from the scene and unitentially fills the whole image. Barthes cites two main factors in a photographic image, studium and punctum. Posted on june 24, 2015 july 6, 2015 by danah hashem. Studium, on the other hand, is what makes a photograph striking as a whole. Mar 05, 2012 how does the studium and the punctum operate for you, consider what affects and moves you personally. The way i understand it, punctum is the element that stands out in a photograph. The punctum is certainly not a punchline and punchline is not any part of this comment. To allow the punctum effect, the viewer must repudiate all knowledge.
The rare experience of punctum art history teaching. The distinction between studium and punctum is the order of liking, not. It can be colors, a cool background, a pose, really anything. Camera lucida is a short book, but with the winter garden photograph it begins all over again. He mentions studium which is the general and historical information present in an image, and punctum something that grabs us, that rises above the scene, that holds our gaze or pricks us. We read from this book on day 1 of class and define studium and punctum collaboratively on the white board. A romanian political prisoner writes her memoir in her head, a book no one will ever read. Punctum can exist alongside studium, but disturbs it, creating an element which rises from the scene and unitentially fills the whole image.
The term relates to the overall interest the photograph has for a viewer and its attractiveness. May 27, 2016 we read from this book on day 1 of class and define studium and punctum collaboratively on the white board. People can like a photograph because of the colors, quality, filters, gradient, etc. The studium and the punctum, tied as they are to the subjective. He doesnt think there is an rule for the connection between the punctum and the studium. This is the socially accepted interpretation of the photographs meaning. The second part of the book is more of a look at specific images and reactions to parts of an image that can cause a photography to have significance. Punctum and studium i saw this image at the impressions gallery, one of a series of images celebrating the shared history of the uk with pakistan. In view of the history of recurring meningitis, search of the childs skin then showed a small punctum in the back of the neck. Roland barthes on photographing the unconscious in camera.
One might think of it as the black dot which disrupts the white page. Studium y punctum roland barthes clases hipermedia. There, i gave what i considered the gist of barthes thesis on camera lucida, the main point you as a photographer can take away from the book. The first, which he calls the studium, is the manifest subject, meaning and. The overall project of barthes camera lucida is to determine a new mode of observation and, ultimately, a new consciousness by way of photography. The basics of studium and punctum in photo a phlearn.
In fact, there may be no punctum for viewers who have become so exposed to the famous image in a studium sense that we no longer read or react to it. The studium refers to the range of meanings available and obvious to everyone. It is simultaneously an inquiry into both the nature and the essence of photography as well as a eulogy to his late mother. Barthes insists that the punctum is not simply the sum of desires projected into the photograph. It becomes an important part of how we look at the photograph and resonates with the viewer so that we might think further about the image, even beyond it. The winter garden photograph, which is not present in the book. Camera lucida book project gutenberg selfpublishing. Please feel free to contact us with any questions, comments, or custom inquiries. There were certain things that i needed to check up on.
607 1115 1499 116 177 1050 940 951 756 1260 297 30 76 1425 1124 42 627 106 1471 1099 237 95 1471 145 610 309 1373 50 1280 1315 636 1479 1433